Thiram treated seed! Good to use or bad?
-
Howdy folks! I’m taking a break from outside work (really the heat) and thought I’d pick your alls brains on this topic.
What is your opinion on treated seed? especially thiram fungicide?
Does it actually help or not?
Does it pass on to the plant and later produce harvested ending up in our bellys?
Does anybody use much treated seed anymore with more health awareness everywhere?I try not to use very much myself but I did last year on my sweet corn. (free sample) Interesting enough, the mole/vole ate it well. I replanted 6 times before outwitting him. ( or he got full and died from overeating) I really didn’t see that much advantage over my untreated seed. Any thoughts?
1 thumbs up!Posted almost 2 years ago -
If my kids can’t touch it to plant it I don’t want to grow it. Honestly I haven’t had much problem with seed rot so I don’t see much point in using it.
My experience is that your seeds also have a great germination rate so that is reassurance as well. If I can grow foods as organic as I can I feel loads better eating them.
-
2 thumbs up!Posted almost 2 years ago
-
Please explain what is Thiram treated seed? (I could google, but I will leave that to you).
-
0 thumbs up!Posted almost 2 years ago
-
source: Wikipedia:
An ectoparasiticide is an antiparasitic drug used in the treatment of ectoparasitic infestations.1
An example is lindane.Acute Toxicity
Thiram is moderately toxic by ingestion, but it is highly toxic if inhaled. Acute exposure in humans may cause headaches, dizziness, fatigue, nausea, diarrhea and other gastrointestinal complaints. 5
Thiram is irritating to the eyes, skin and respiratory tract. It is a skin sensitizer. Symptoms of acute inhalation exposure to thiram include itching, scratchy throat, hoarseness, sneezing, coughing, inflammation of the nose or throat, bronchitis, dizziness, headaches, fatigue, nausea, diarrhea and other gastro-intestinal complaints. Persons with chronic respiratory or skin disease are at increased risk from exposure to thiram.
I suppose I am a purist. I’d rather the rot get my seeds.
-
1 thumbs up!Posted almost 2 years ago
-
[This post has been removed by the poster.]
-
-
Tralamander, plants can “take in” all sorts of chemicals besides CO2, water and nutrients. Absorption is how systemic herbicides like RoundUp work.
-
3 thumbs up!Posted almost 2 years ago
-
[This post has been removed by the poster.]
-
-
@ hillbillyharvey ~ maybe your mole/vole died of fungicide? :-P
@ Fhaith who said _"My experience is that your seeds also have a great germination rate so that is reassurance as well. If I can grow foods as organic as I can I feel loads better eating them." _ ~ Too, too very true!
Hillbillyharvey ~ Please, please continue to sell only your untreated seeds. They have germinated well and grown wonderfully :)
-
1 thumbs up!Posted almost 2 years ago | Last edited almost 2 years ago
-
The issue of using chemicals or no chemicals is personal choice. But herbicides and pesticides do have impact in any implication or application. They do affect the plant as they are being directly exposed to toxins so the bugs or any opportunist organism will die or be staved off in order for the food source to grow. These toxins are now in the garden, the fields, the acres and acres of land worldwide.
I have spent most of my life gardening organically and it has taken me 25 years just to use insecticidal soap because I have an infestation of squash bugs. I am lucky. If we paid attention to our natural world and respected it more we wouldn’t spray one gram of toxin on any of our consumable foods or consumables we feed our soon to be slaughtered animals. They eat whatever they are given – toxins, hormones, antibiotics… and in turn we absorb this and our bodies react to what it is given.
It is a chain – and it does get into the environment due to farmer application and it has a far reaching effect in the ecosystem with algae bloom from water run off from farms. It’s not just about one plant. It’s about the health of the whole.
Insecticides and herbicides are something I choose not use and it has a strong intentionality of purpose behind that practice. My grandfather died of kidney cancer because he was a groundskeeper/gardener and he practiced using chemicals to control weeds and insects. I never had a chance to meet him. So this is very personal to me and my concern for humankind.
-
1 thumbs up!Posted almost 2 years ago
-
I’m still not sure that’s accurate, Tralamander. I am not a biologist or botanist either, but my curiosity is piqued and I will have to do some more reading.
I am now thinking of Plants that are resistant to certain pesticides and herbicides, either naturally or through vendor modification.
I have read reports that (though not the actual studies) residual glyphosate in roundup ready corn/soy is making people sick. I think we talked about this here recently. In these ass’s, plants are taking uP the chemical but it doesn’t kill them. Of course, those particular varieties are genetically engineered, but those genes had parents in nature once upon a time, right?
Anyway, I don’t know enough about the subject to comment further, at least not until learning more.
I have no experience with seed treated with Thiram, obviously, but did want to note we had a recent discussion here in the general forum regarding legumes treated with “innoculant”
THat might interest you, Harvey b -
1 thumbs up!Posted almost 2 years ago
-
Glyphosate is banned in some areas because of this. is also much in need of more reading Thanks!
/edit: I have removed my hippy, opinionated musings in favour of real science which people here are kind enough to provide. -
0 thumbs up!Posted almost 2 years ago | Last edited almost 2 years ago
-
Thanks everybody for the feedback!
Orenda@ Don’t worry, we at White Harvest Seed don’t plan on adding any treated seed to our inventory.
Fhaith & creme@ Thanks for your words. There is lots of passion & wisdom there that I agree with!
Tralamander@ I think folks might benefit more if they used some old “hippy” ideas. Self-sufficient living, more health & environment awareness, neighbors helping/sharing/co-ops neighbors, and just plain respect and concern for one another. (I have to be careful here cause if I said “grow your own” it might be taken differently! lol) -
1 thumbs up!Posted almost 2 years ago
-
Tralamander, oh! I wish you hadn’t deleted! That makes things confusing to read, though hopefully future readers will understand through context.
I hippy-dippy too, but with a punk edge :) I suspect there is something to your idea (that plants take up only CO2, h2o and specific nutrient) – but I think it’s also more complicated and less general than that. You definitely have started an interesting side topic here and one I want to learn more about.
-
0 thumbs up!Posted almost 2 years ago
-
Cases not asses.
-
0 thumbs up!Posted almost 2 years ago
-
I get my passion from my father who is an PHD environmental ethicist with research on toxins in the environment. He also taught at Cornell. Not the typical hippy influence. I missed the comment so I can’t comment on context. But what is most important as that it is balanced with fact. I guess I just discovered I am more of a purist than I gave myself credit for! But passion is one of my stronger points so if I came across to strongly my apologies.
-
1 thumbs up!Posted almost 2 years ago
-
Nice connections, faith! (Tucks tidbit into memory bank for future reference).
-
0 thumbs up!Posted almost 2 years ago
-
I am a scientist, and not a hippy, but have observed that many toxic chemicals are pushed into use by the chemical industry that are absolutely not needed or beneficial in any way, and often are much more harmful than advertised. I dont see why you would even consider this unless you have had a lot of serious problems with seed rot.
-
1 thumbs up!Posted almost 2 years ago | Last edited almost 2 years ago
-
I’m quite concerned about the lack of really serious, long term testing on many chemicals. Even when tests are done, industry cover-ups happen (see: Monsanto). And then even if a company acts in good faith, and even it is stringent in testing, and even when the FDA agrees that something is safe enough to release (really this means not harmful enough to not release) – mistakes happen as we have seen in the recent reports of the newly approved lawn chemical now known to be killing off pine trees.
anelson, you know I’m curious now. Can you tell us what your job is? (Or can you tell me via pm?)
-
1 thumbs up!Posted almost 2 years ago
-
So, self discovery of purism, and trust no one in power that sells chemicals for gardens who has invested money in having one buy said chemicals. All the Madoffs of commercialism basically. A lot of trust issues I guess. Oh,and i am a hippy. But one who does not smoke or inhale…. anymore. Years, nay decades ago… there. I’ve said it. Not running for presidency so I guess I am safe. Feels good coming out out of the closet. Phew.
-
0 thumbs up!Posted almost 2 years ago
-
Fhaith@ Now I know why I like you so much! We have things in common………………………………… a lack of trust in corporate business.
What did you think I was going to say? LOL I would lose all my credibility on folia if I came clean! LOL
-
0 thumbs up!Posted almost 2 years ago
-
LOL!!! Too funny!!!
-
0 thumbs up!Posted almost 2 years ago
-
I raise my glass to credibility Cheers!
-
0 thumbs up!Posted almost 2 years ago
-
creme its a bit embarrassing but i will confess my profession—professor of physics.
-
2 thumbs up!Posted almost 2 years ago
-
Physics is respectable Anelson!
-
0 thumbs up!Posted almost 2 years ago
-
Dang. That’s not embarrassing at all. I just got a little geeked out. :)
-
0 thumbs up!Posted almost 2 years ago
-
In case you all missed it, here is a link to the discussion thread on Imperilis herbicide implicated in killing off trees that I mentioned above:
-
0 thumbs up!Posted almost 2 years ago
-
Non-treated sugary enhanced sweet corn struggles to germinate in my cold clayish soil. Thiram treated seed germinates fine for me. But after working in pesticide research and development for 20 years, I do not invite poisons into my garden. I am dealing with the germination issue by developing an open pollinated sugary enhanced sweet corn and screening for good germination in my soil. (And by planting other types of corn in early spring.)
-
2 thumbs up!Posted 11 months ago
Hi there! You're reading a conversation in the White Harvest Seed Company group on Folia.
White Harvest Seed Company chat and discussion
Topic Watchers
Other Recent Topics See more...
- 0 What's Your Favorite Gardening Book? in the White Harvest Seed Company group Posted by Savanna 16 days ago.
- 31 Introduction of New Heirloom Seed Company in the White Harvest Seed Company group Posted by hillbillyharvey over 2 years ago. Last reply by crochetkim 3 months ago.
- 10 "Out with the Old - In with the New" in the White Harvest Seed Company group Posted by Savanna 6 months ago. Last reply by Savanna 4 months ago.
- 2 Fall Planting Guide question(s) in the White Harvest Seed Company group Posted by JimMarconnet 11 months ago. Last reply by JimMarconnet 10 months ago.
- 3 Featured Gardeners Needed for White Harvest Website in the White Harvest Seed Company group Posted by hillbillyharvey 11 months ago. Last reply by hillbillyharvey 11 months ago.



